Why 'You Can't Serve Two Masters' Is the Book the American Church Needs Right Now

Something has gone wrong in the American Church. Most people can feel it. Fewer are willing to say it.

We have churches that are growing and congregations that are shrinking. We have worship music on every streaming platform and biblical illiteracy at an all-time high. We have more Christian content than any generation in history, and less Christian conviction.

The problem is not that the Church lacks resources. The problem is that the Church lacks allegiance.

Drew Reitzel’s forthcoming book, You Can’t Serve Two Masters: Undivided Allegiance to Christ in an Age of Cultural Compromise, says what the pulpit has gone quiet about. It is not another self-help book with a cross on the cover. It is a prophetic call to the American Church to stop choosing cultural approval over biblical fidelity, and to confront the cost of that choice before it’s too late.

Why Does the American Church Need This Book Right Now?

Because the numbers confirm what the Spirit has been saying for years.

According to the American Worldview Inventory 2025 from Arizona Christian University’s Cultural Research Center, only 4% of American adults hold a biblical worldview. Among born-again Christians, people who would say they have a personal relationship with Jesus, that number rises to just 13%.

Let that settle. Thirteen percent.

The vast majority of people who call themselves Christians in America do not think biblically. They think culturally. They have absorbed the values of the world and baptized them with Christian language, and the result is a faith that looks like the culture it was supposed to transform.

This is not a problem that more programs will fix. It is not a problem that a better worship set will fix. It is a crisis of allegiance, and it demands a prophetic voice, not a marketing strategy.

You Can’t Serve Two Masters is that voice. Where most Christian books tiptoe around the tension between faith and culture, this one walks straight into it. Where most authors soften the diagnosis to avoid offense, Reitzel names the disease: the Church is not drifting, it is choosing.

What Is This Book Actually About?

At its core, You Can’t Serve Two Masters makes one argument: the American Church has exchanged biblical faithfulness for cultural approval, and it has done so knowingly.

The book doesn’t dance around the evidence. It addresses the specific ways compromise has taken root, the silencing of the pulpit, the avoidance of abortion, the cultural redefinition of marriage, and the cheap grace that has replaced the costly Gospel Jesus actually preached. These are not political talking points in Reitzel’s hands. They are theological diagnoses.

And that distinction matters.

The Difference Between a Political Book and a Prophetic One

A political book takes a side. A prophetic book takes a stand.

You Can’t Serve Two Masters is not a manifesto for the right or the left. It doesn’t pledge allegiance to a party. It pledges allegiance to Christ, and then measures everything else against that standard. Both sides of the political spectrum will find themselves challenged. That’s how you know it’s prophetic and not partisan.

The book’s subtitle says it plainly: Undivided Allegiance to Christ in an Age of Cultural Compromise. Not undivided allegiance to a platform. Not undivided allegiance to a movement. To Christ. That changes everything about how the argument unfolds.

Who Should Read This Book?

Every pastor who has felt the pressure to soften the message. Every church leader who has watched their denomination quietly revise what it believes. Every Christian who sits in a pew on Sunday and senses that something essential has gone missing but can’t quite name it.

This book is for all of them.

But pastors especially.

Why Pastors Especially Need to Read This

A Barna and Gloo study found that 38% of pastors have seriously considered quitting full-time ministry. Among the top reasons? Political division. Cultural pressure. The overwhelming stress of being asked to lead on issues they feel unequipped to address. Forty-five percent of pastors say politics and civic engagement is the area they are least equipped to handle.

That’s not surprising. Pastors have been trained to preach and counsel and lead worship, not to stand in the crossfire of a culture war they didn’t start. But the crossfire found them anyway.

You Can’t Serve Two Masters doesn’t leave pastors in that crossfire alone. It gives them a framework: this isn’t about politics. It’s about allegiance. And once a pastor sees the issue through that lens, the fear of controversy starts to lose its grip. The question stops being “Will people leave my church?” and starts being “Am I faithful to the One who called me?”

“This is the book the Church needs but fears to read. Every pastor in America should have a copy.”

John Dillon, Undivided Allegiance, Orlando, FL

What Makes Drew Reitzel’s Voice Unique?

Most Christian authors write from one world. They are academics or pastors or theologians, people whose entire life has been spent inside the walls of the church.

Reitzel writes from two.

He holds a degree in theology. He has years of pastoral ministry behind him. But he also has more than 25 years in the marketplace, in business, in leadership, in the real-world environments where faith either means something or it doesn’t. That combination matters because so much of the Church’s compromise is driven by the same forces that drive the marketplace: pragmatism, audience management, and the relentless pursuit of growth at any cost.

Reitzel sees those patterns because he has lived in both worlds. He recognizes when the Church is running on a business model instead of a biblical mandate. And he says so, not from academic detachment, but from personal conviction forged in spiritual mountaintops and valleys alike.

This is not a book written by someone who studied the problem. It’s a book written by someone who has felt it.

How Does the Book Handle the Most Divisive Issues?

Directly. That’s the short answer.

Where most churches tiptoe around abortion, You Can’t Serve Two Masters speaks with biblical clarity. Where denominations have quietly revised their positions on marriage, this book holds the line, not out of cruelty, but out of faithfulness to what Scripture actually says. Where the prosperity gospel and its softer cousin, therapeutic Christianity, have replaced the God of Scripture with a god of comfort, Reitzel calls it what it is: idolatry dressed in worship music.

These are not easy chapters. They won’t make you feel good. But conviction rarely does.

The Silencing of the Pulpit

Here is the quiet crisis underneath all the others: pastors have stopped preaching on the things that matter most. Not because they don’t believe them, but because the cost of saying them out loud has become too high.

Only 20% of pastors say they feel equipped to lead on politics and civic engagement, according to Barna research. But the issue isn’t really politics. It’s courage. When did we decide that faithfulness to God’s Word was optional if it made people uncomfortable?

The pulpit was never meant to be a safe space. It was meant to be a sacred one. And there is a difference.

You Can’t Serve Two Masters addresses this silence not with condemnation but with an invitation, an invitation to remember what the pulpit is for and to use it accordingly.

What Does “Undivided Allegiance” Actually Look Like?

Jesus said it plainly: “No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other” (Matthew 6:24).

We quote that verse about money. We rarely apply it to culture. But the principle is the same. You cannot pledge allegiance to Christ and to the approval of a culture that has rejected Him. You cannot hold the Bible in one hand and the spirit of the age in the other. At some point, you will have to choose.

The book makes this choice concrete. It’s not an abstraction. It’s not a theology lecture. It’s a mirror, held up to the Church, to its leaders, and to every individual believer who has quietly negotiated with compromise because faithfulness felt too expensive.

From Diagnosis to Decision

This is where the book separates itself from every other critique of the American Church. It doesn’t just name the problem. It calls for a response.

Repentance. Not the soft, therapeutic kind that modern Christianity has invented, the biblical kind. The kind that means turning around entirely. The kind that costs something.

The invitation at the heart of You Can’t Serve Two Masters is the oldest invitation in Scripture: Choose this day whom you will serve.

The book simply asks: Have you?

When Does the Book Release?

You Can’t Serve Two Masters: Undivided Allegiance to Christ in an Age of Cultural Compromise releases on April 30, 2026.

If this post named something you’ve been feeling, if you’ve sensed the compromise, felt the tension, or wondered whether anyone was going to say it out loud, this book was written for you.

Sign up for the newsletter to be notified on release day, and follow along at undividedallegiance.com as we count down to launch.

Share this with a pastor who needs to hear it. Share it with a friend who’s been asking the hard questions. The Church doesn’t need more silence. It needs more voices willing to say what’s true, no matter the cost.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is “You Can’t Serve Two Masters” about?

It’s a prophetic call to the American Church to choose biblical fidelity over cultural compromise. The book addresses the silencing of the pulpit, the Church’s posture on abortion and marriage, and the cheap grace that has replaced the costly Gospel, all through the lens of allegiance to Christ, not politics.

Who is Drew Reitzel?

Drew Reitzel holds a theology degree and has years of pastoral ministry experience alongside more than 25 years in the business world. He writes from the intersection of deep theological conviction and real-world application, a voice shaped by both the pulpit and the marketplace.

Is this a political book?

No. While it addresses culturally charged issues, the book’s framework is allegiance to Christ, not allegiance to a party, a movement, or a political platform. Both sides of the aisle will find themselves challenged, which is exactly the point.

When does “You Can’t Serve Two Masters” come out?

The book releases on April 30, 2026. Sign up at undividedallegiance.com to be notified on release day and receive updates leading up to launch.